← Back to case studies
Case law
Ansbro v Marshall Motor Group Limited

Being quietly passed over for a role a male colleague gets can be unlawful.

The ruling

Constructive dismissal and sex discrimination both succeeded.”

If someone of a different sex is given a promotion or expanded role you were never told about or allowed to apply for, that can be unlawful sex discrimination, regardless of what your employer calls the change internally.

  • Note down when you found out about the other person's new role, and how, while it is still fresh in your mind.
  • A short email to your employer works. Ask why you weren't given the chance to apply, and save whatever comes back.
  • If you are considering resigning over this, get advice first. The time limit runs from your resignation date and how you handle it affects your claim.
Read the full case

The situation

A senior compliance manager spent years building her team and was well regarded, including at board level. When her employer was bought by a larger group, her team lost two people during a difficult regulatory deadline and was never fully replaced. Her employer then quietly moved a colleague from elsewhere in the group into an expanded compliance role, without ever telling her the opportunity existed or letting her apply for it. She resigned soon after and brought a claim.

What the tribunal found

The tribunal found she had been constructively and unfairly dismissed, and that failing to give her the chance to apply for the new role was direct sex discrimination under section 13 of the Equality Act 2010. Her employer argued no new role had been created at all, just an extension of an existing one. The tribunal did not accept that this made a difference: whatever the internal label, the practical effect was that only a male colleague ever had the chance to be considered for it. Her other discrimination and harassment complaints were not upheld.

Full citation

Ansbro v Marshall Motor Group Limited. Case 2411380/2023 & 2400164/2024. Manchester Employment Tribunal. April 2026.

Last reviewed 6 July 2026