← Back to case studies
Case law
Lewis v H Newton Hale & Sons Ltd (in creditors voluntary liquidation)

If your employer skipped redundancy consultation altogether, you could be owed up to three months’ extra pay.

The ruling

“Tribunal awarded the statutory maximum 90-day protective award.”

A failure to consult before redundancies doesn't disappear just because the business has gone under, and it can be worth months of extra pay.

  • Check whether you were consulted yourself, or through properly elected staff representatives, before your redundancy was confirmed. If neither happened, that is worth challenging.
  • If 20 or more people at your workplace were being made redundant together, consultation should have started well before any dismissals took effect, not after they had already been decided.
  • If your employer has gone into liquidation or administration, get advice early. You can usually still bring a claim, but the process and time limits can be confusing, and it helps to have someone check the details against what actually happened.
Read the full case

The situation

An employee at H Newton Hale & Sons Limited was made redundant when the company went into creditors' voluntary liquidation. Before the redundancies went ahead, the company never held the election for staff representatives that the law requires when a business proposes to make a group of employees redundant together. When the employee brought a tribunal claim over this, the company did not defend it and did not attend the hearing.

What the tribunal found

The tribunal found in the employee's favour. Under section 188 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, an employer proposing to make a group of staff redundant together must either consult recognised employee representatives or hold an election so staff can choose their own. H Newton Hale & Sons Limited did neither. Because the company did not appear to explain or defend its position, the tribunal ordered the maximum penalty available: a protective award of 90 days' pay under section 189(3) of the Act, running from 1 August 2025.

Full citation

Lewis v H Newton Hale & Sons Ltd (in creditors voluntary liquidation). Case 6034662/2025. Employment Tribunal. May 2026.

Last reviewed 17 July 2026